Judgment, Mercy & Looking Beyond Appearances

Watch on Rumble

Wolves & Wisemen Reignited — Episode 17

View Episode Now

About This Episode

Everybody judges.

Sometimes we do it without even realizing it.

We see the tattoos.

The clothes.

The hair.

The neighborhood.

The bumper sticker.

The political shirt.

But is all judgment wrong?

Episode 17 of Wolves & Wisemen Reignited digs into judgment, mercy, hypocrisy, discernment and what Scripture actually tells us about how we should see other people.

Using John 7:24 and James 2:13, the guys ask an important question:

What's the difference between judging somebody unfairly and using good judgment?

That leads into conversations about tattoos, stereotypes, parenting, road rage, politics, different backgrounds and how easily our first impressions become assumptions.

Then another passage brings the conversation even closer to home:

Before worrying about the speck in somebody else's eye...

What about the plank in your own?

The guys talk openly about their own hypocrisy, mistakes and tendency to judge people—and why mercy becomes a lot easier when you remember you've screwed up too.

Later, Fringe Files gets weird again with one of the strangest stories we've covered:

Gef the Talking Mongoose.

Was Gef an elaborate hoax?

A poltergeist?

An unknown creature?

Something spiritual?

Or just a family on an isolated farm with one hell of a story?

That rabbit hole eventually brings the conversation right back to Scripture and another question:

If God used an animal to speak to someone in the Bible, would we even recognize it if something like that happened today?

What We Talk About

The Check In — Judgment & Mercy

John 7:24

James 2:13

Judging people by appearance

Judgment versus discernment

Tattoos and first impressions

Stereotypes

Character versus appearance

Mercy before judgment

Remembering that you don't know what someone else is going through

Road rage and everyday judgment

The speck and the plank

Hypocrisy

Holding others to standards you don't follow yourself

Parenting versus judging

Teaching children through your own mistakes

Consequences

Political division

Being able to disagree without hating each other

Helping people regardless of their politics

Looking at character instead of labels

Elsewhere in Episode 17

Rebel Report

The Super Bowl and competing halftime shows

America's growing political and cultural division

Social media

TikTok privacy and strange search suggestions

Technology and privacy

Ring cameras and tracking technology

Sacked

Folks on Fire

God Sign Post and giving bicycles to kids

Today in History

Boners

Gef the Talking Mongoose

Talking animals throughout history and folklore

Balaam's donkey

The serpent in Genesis

The burning bush

Discernment

God, deception and recognizing the difference

AI and whether modern technology makes strange experiences harder to trust

Scripture From This Episode

John 7:24

“Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment.”

This verse becomes the foundation of the first Check In.

There's an important distinction here.

Scripture isn't telling us to abandon every form of judgment or discernment.

It's warning against making judgments based simply on what somebody looks like.

Robert connects this to his own experience being heavily tattooed.

Someone can see tattoos and immediately begin building assumptions about that person.

But appearance doesn't tell you everything about character.

At the same time, the guys recognize that human beings make judgments every day.

If something feels dangerous, you react.

If someone has repeatedly shown themselves to be untrustworthy, you remember it.

If you're responsible for your children, you take precautions.

The question becomes:

Are you judging somebody's character based on evidence—or writing their story based on their appearance?

Those aren't necessarily the same thing.

James 2:13

“For judgment is without mercy to one who has shown no mercy. Mercy triumphs over judgment.”

This shifts the conversation.

Instead of asking only whether we're allowed to judge, maybe there's a better question:

Are we approaching people with judgment first—or mercy first?

You don't know what somebody dealt with before crossing your path.

Maybe they're struggling.

Maybe they're grieving.

Maybe they're angry.

Maybe they made a mistake.

Maybe they're simply having one of the worst days of their life.

That doesn't excuse every action.

But it might change how you respond.

Mercy doesn't require pretending wrong is right.

Sometimes it simply means remembering that the person standing in front of you is imperfect...

just like you.

The Speck & the Plank

Another passage comes up that perfectly connects the first two.

Before trying to remove the speck from somebody else's eye...

Deal with the plank in your own.

The guys connect this to the old saying:

When you point one finger at somebody else, three are pointing back at you.

It's easy to notice somebody else's failures.

It's considerably harder to acknowledge your own.

And if you're condemning somebody for something you've done yourself?

Maybe the first conversation needs to happen with the person in the mirror.

Key Takeaways

Appearance isn't character. Tattoos, clothing, hair and other outward appearances don't automatically tell you who somebody is.

Judgment and discernment aren't necessarily the same thing. Recognizing danger, patterns or consequences can be different from condemning someone based on assumptions.

Mercy should come before condemnation. You rarely know everything another person is dealing with.

Check your own plank first. Before tearing somebody apart for their mistakes, remember your own.

Experience can become compassion. If you've made the same mistake, maybe you're uniquely positioned to understand instead of condemn.

Parenting isn't about pretending you never screwed up. Sometimes your mistakes are exactly why you're trying to keep your children from repeating them.

Consequences still matter. Mercy doesn't mean eliminating accountability.

Your first reaction can change. Instead of immediately seeing someone different from you as an enemy, you can choose curiosity, conversation and compassion.

Political disagreement doesn't have to destroy relationships. People can disagree and still help each other, talk to each other and treat each other like human beings.

Character matters more than labels. How somebody treats people tells you considerably more than a stereotype does.

The Check In — Don't Judge the Cover

The conversation begins with something simple:

Tattoos.

Robert talks about walking into expensive homes while working in the fireplace industry and immediately noticing people staring at his arms.

The questions would start.

What does that tattoo mean?

What's that one?

What's this?

And sometimes you could feel that an opinion had already been formed before the conversation even started.

But tattoos aren't character.

Neither is someone's hair.

Their clothes.

Their neighborhood.

Their job.

Or plenty of the other things we use to quickly categorize people.

That doesn't mean throwing common sense away.

It means recognizing when common sense turns into condemnation.

Judgment vs. Discernment

One of the best questions in the episode comes from a simple scenario.

You're sitting at a stoplight with your children.

You're in an area that doesn't feel particularly safe.

You lock the doors.

Did you just judge somebody?

Maybe.

But there's also a difference between protecting yourself and deciding another person's entire moral character based on how they look.

That's where discernment matters.

Christianity doesn't require walking blindly through life.

But it does challenge us to examine why we're making the judgments we're making.

Is it evidence?

Experience?

Safety?

Or simply:

“That person isn't like me.”

Mercy Triumphs Over Judgment

James 2:13 brings the entire discussion back to mercy.

This doesn't mean people never face consequences.

It doesn't mean every decision is acceptable.

It doesn't mean ignoring dangerous behavior.

It means starting from the recognition that we're all imperfect.

The guy who cut you off in traffic might be an idiot.

Or maybe he's racing somewhere because something terrible happened.

You don't know.

And sometimes remembering that is enough to stop a moment of frustration from becoming something bigger.

The guys aren't pretending they're great at this.

Road rage alone proves there's still work to do.

But that's part of the point.

Faith isn't about claiming you've already mastered the lesson.

Sometimes it's recognizing what you're supposed to be working on.

Take the Plank Out First

The speck-and-plank conversation may be the clearest summary of Episode 17.

How can you condemn somebody for something you're doing yourself?

That idea comes up repeatedly.

Work.

Parenting.

Driving.

Leadership.

Relationships.

It's difficult to demand a standard from someone else while refusing to apply it to yourself.

And sometimes your own mistakes should make you more understanding, not more judgmental.

Because you've been there.

You know what happens next.

You know the consequences.

You know how difficult climbing back out can be.

Maybe your experience wasn't given to you so you could look down on the next person.

Maybe it helps you reach them.

Parenting, Mistakes & Learning the Hard Way

Parenting becomes a perfect example.

When your child starts making some of the exact mistakes you made...

you aren't necessarily judging them.

Sometimes you're desperately trying to keep them from learning everything the same painful way you did.

You've already touched the stove.

You already know it's hot.

Your kid doesn't need to burn their hand just to confirm your research.

Of course...

sometimes they're going to touch it anyway.

Especially when they're exactly like you.

And that may be one of parenting's cruelest jokes.

Division & Seeing People as People

Eventually the conversation expands beyond individual judgment into the larger cultural divide.

Politics.

Police.

Dating.

Social media.

Different lifestyles.

Different opinions.

We've reached a point where people sometimes decide they can't even speak to somebody who voted differently from them.

The guys question what happens when disagreement becomes automatic hatred.

You might disagree with somebody on ten different issues.

But if they're stranded with a flat tire?

Are you going to help them?

Hopefully.

Because underneath all the labels is still another person.

The guys don't suggest everybody suddenly needs to agree.

They suggest something much simpler:

Learn how to disagree without forgetting how to treat people.

Folks on Fire

One of the more meaningful shout-outs goes to God Sign Post, another creator who joins the Wolves in the chat.

The guys learned that he fixes up bicycles and gives them to people and kids who otherwise might not have one.

That hits especially close to home because Robert talks about growing up without a bike of his own until he was older.

It's a small example of something that fits perfectly with the night's Check In:

You don't always need some enormous platform to make a difference.

Sometimes you see somebody who needs something.

You have the ability to help.

So you help.

That's Folks on Fire.

Technology, Privacy & How Much Is Too Much?

Another conversation asks what happens when technology created for a good purpose becomes capable of something much larger.

The guys discuss camera networks and technology designed to help locate lost pets.

On the surface?

Great idea.

But what happens when similar technology can identify and track people?

Children?

Neighbors?

Anybody captured by a network of connected cameras?

The conversation isn't claiming a specific sinister purpose.

It's asking a broader question:

When does convenience become surveillance?

Technology can solve real problems.

But powerful tools also create powerful opportunities for misuse.

And sometimes the important conversation needs to happen before the technology becomes normal.

Sacked

The show's most intellectually sophisticated segment returns.

People get hit in the nuts.

Episode 17 includes automotive mishaps, bad wrench decisions and another reminder that working on your own vehicle occasionally requires sacrificing your future children to the gods of rusty bolts.

Tony Baker's animal voiceovers also make an appearance.

The theological implications remain under investigation.

Today in History

The guys take another run through history, including conversations about:

The Beatles and their American television breakthrough

The Berlin Wall

Alex Rodriguez and performance-enhancing drugs

Julius Caesar

George Washington Carver

The origins of duct tape

Somewhere along the way, the historical accuracy becomes secondary to making fun of each other's age.

As tradition demands.

Boners

One of the evening's Boners demonstrates an important lesson:

There are some things you can't unsee.

In this case...

Toenails.

Very long toenails.

The kind of toenails that make you wonder whether someone is preparing to climb a telephone pole without using their hands.

Sometimes Boners is about terrible decisions.

Sometimes it's about ridiculous news.

And sometimes it's simply about forcing your cohost to stare at feet for thirty seconds.

Fringe Files — Gef the Talking Mongoose

Then things get weird.

Very weird.

In the early 1930s, a family living at an isolated farmhouse on the Isle of Man claimed something was living inside their walls.

It talked.

It sang.

It reportedly knew things happening outside the house.

It argued with the family.

It supposedly killed rabbits.

It swore.

It mocked the neighbors.

And it said its name was:

Gef.

Pronounced...

Jeff.

Because apparently even paranormal mongooses enjoy making things unnecessarily complicated.

What Was Gef?

The story attracted newspapers and paranormal investigators and eventually became one of the stranger paranormal cases of the twentieth century.

But there was a problem.

Evidence was limited.

So several explanations emerged.

Maybe the family's daughter was throwing her voice.

Maybe it was poltergeist activity.

Maybe Gef was some unknown animal.

Maybe isolation, stress and imagination played a role.

Or maybe...

there really was a foul-mouthed mongoose living inside the walls.

The Wolves naturally investigate all possibilities with the level of academic discipline you've come to expect.

Talking Animals & the Bible

But Gef opens a much more interesting biblical conversation.

Because talking animals aren't completely foreign to Scripture.

There's the serpent in Genesis.

There's Balaam's donkey.

And throughout the Bible there are moments when God communicates with people in ways that would seem impossible under ordinary circumstances.

So the guys ask:

If God used an animal to communicate once, could He do it again?

And if He did...

Would we recognize it?

Or would we assume we'd inhaled too much exhaust while working on an old truck?

God, Deception & Discernment

Then the question becomes more complicated.

Not every supernatural experience would necessarily come from God.

The Bible also warns about deception.

So even if something extraordinary happened, how would somebody know where it came from?

That brings Fringe Files unexpectedly back to the night's original Check In.

Discernment.

Don't automatically believe everything you see.

Don't automatically dismiss everything you don't understand.

Examine it.

Compare it to Scripture.

Ask questions.

And remember that something being strange doesn't automatically make it divine.

Talking Dogs, Psychic Horses & Demon Cats

Gef isn't alone.

The guys tumble farther down the rabbit hole into stories and traditions involving supposedly unusual animal communication, including:

Talking dogs

Ravens

Psychic horses

The legendary Demon Cat of the U.S. Capitol

Indigenous traditions involving animal messengers

Apes communicating through signs

Other alleged talking-animal encounters

Some have ordinary explanations.

Some are folklore.

Some are disputed paranormal claims.

And some are just wonderfully strange stories.

Fringe Files explores these accounts as stories, legends, theories and questions—not established evidence of supernatural talking animals.

What If an Animal Talked to You?

That's where the episode lands on a genuinely interesting question.

Imagine you're walking tomorrow morning.

A squirrel comes down from a tree.

Looks directly at you.

And starts talking.

What's your first thought?

God?

The devil?

AI?

Mental breakdown?

Carbon-monoxide poisoning?

Probably not divine revelation.

And that's part of the point.

We live in a world of artificial intelligence, edited video, algorithms, deepfakes and endless digital manipulation.

We've become skeptical of practically everything.

So if something truly extraordinary happened...

Would modern people even recognize it?

The Bigger Conversation

Episode 17 starts with judgment.

But underneath the jokes, arguments, tattoos, politics, bad drivers, weird toenails and talking mongooses is a much simpler message.

You don't know somebody's entire story by looking at them.

You don't know what happened yesterday.

You don't know what they're fighting.

You don't know what mistakes they've already overcome.

And you probably have a few things in your own life worth fixing before dedicating all your energy to theirs.

That doesn't mean abandoning discernment.

It doesn't mean pretending right and wrong don't exist.

And it doesn't mean ignoring consequences.

It means remembering mercy.

Jesus didn't ask us to become perfect people who spend our lives identifying everyone else's imperfections.

We're supposed to keep working on ourselves too.

Maybe somebody looks different from you.

Maybe they vote differently.

Maybe they believe differently.

Maybe they've made decisions you wouldn't make.

Have the conversation anyway.

Listen.

Help when you can.

Share your faith when the opportunity is there.

And before throwing the stone...

Check your own hands.

Watch & Listen

Watch the full episode and join the conversation.

Follow Wolves & Wisemen Reignited

Wolves & Wisemen Reignited is three imperfect guys strengthening their faith while talking honestly about life, brotherhood, Scripture, current events, history, the unexplained and whatever rabbit hole they fall into next.

We don't pretend to have every answer.

We read.

We question.

We talk about it.

And we're learning as we go.

New episodes every Tuesday night.

Like. Follow. Subscribe. Join the chat.

And remember:

Mercy triumphs over judgment.